I've been reading all these threads about weight and models and stuff.I just want to know what size you guys think is fat and what size you think is too skinny.After reading all the threads I'm confused.

Hm, in American sizes I think a 5 and up is at least chubby. Don't listen to me though, I'm used to being a 00.

Well..I personally think that 0-1 is too skinny, and 14 plus is too big.

it depends on the person's frame.

the 5 and up I could perrrrsonally agree with if it deals with innactive people, but I know very fit athletes that wear larger sizes.

it depends on the person's frame.

the 5 and up I could perrrrsonally agree with if it deals with innactive people, but I know very fit athletes that wear larger sizes.

Hypocrite.

Hm, in American sizes I think a 5 and up is at least chubby. Don't listen to me though, I'm used to being a 00.
I'm a size 5:(

Hey wasn't Marilyn Monroe kinda chubby?

I'm a size 5:(

Hey wasn't Marilyn Monroe kinda chubby?

From her pictures I thought she was. But, it was a picture, and from the ones she had on her myspace, its hard to tell.

But, don't worry size 5 isn't chubby. You can't really say who is and who isn't chubby unless you've seen them. It really depends on how your built. When I tell people that I'm a size 7 they dont believe me.

From her pictures I thought she was. But, it was a picture, and from the ones she had on her myspace, its hard to tell.

But, don't worry size 5 isn't chubby. You can't really say who is and who isn't chubby unless you've seen them. It really depends on how your built. When I tell people that I'm a size 7 they dont believe me.
I didn't mean Marilyn_Monroe.I mean the dead celeb one.

lmao oops..

lmao oops..
It's okay,it was kinda funny.;)

Marilyn Monroe was a healthy weight, but she also had a great body to begin with.

marilyn monroe is dead and this is just another arguement waiting to happen

Marilyn Monroe was a healthy weight, but she also had a great body to begin with.

Marilyn Monroe was a voluptuous size 10. But that was the fashion back in the day. The sort of womanly look. :shrug:


I'm a size 4. I don't think I'm skinny, but I don't think I'm chubby either. To be honest, I don't think about my weight much. I'm on the track team and run about 5 miles a day, 5 times a week. I'm a vegetarian and enjoy eating reasonably healthy food. If people think I'm chubby, then I honestly could care less because I do everything I can to remain in good health.

Aussie I totally agree with you, I think I told someone that same thing a few weeks ago. Like she was saying all these good things about her, and then I said she is also dead.

From her pictures I thought she was. But, it was a picture, and from the ones she had on her myspace, its hard to tell.

But, don't worry size 5 isn't chubby. You can't really say who is and who isn't chubby unless you've seen them. It really depends on how your built. When I tell people that I'm a size 7 they dont believe me.

From my pictures you thought I was chubby? I have no body pictures on myspace, and those are the only ones you've seen.

PS: I'm basing the size 5 thing on my older sister, but she looks chubbier because of her ginormous boobs. My friend is a size 5 and I could swear she's a 2.

Aussie I totally agree with you, I think I told someone that same thing a few weeks ago. Like she was saying all these good things about her, and then I said she is also dead.
haha some people just can't let go of the past.. :rolleyes:

Yes, Marilyn Monroe was chubby. This has nothing to do with me however.

Hypocrite.


did you not see the emphasis I placed on "personally"?

Oh, and I didn't say I thought chubby was a bad thing. Some girl's faces look nicer when they are thicker rather than thinner.

From her pictures I thought she was. But, it was a picture, and from the ones she had on her myspace, its hard to tell.

But, don't worry size 5 isn't chubby. You can't really say who is and who isn't chubby unless you've seen them. It really depends on how your built. When I tell people that I'm a size 7 they dont believe me.


Size 7 looks chubby on some people but it looks thin on others. My friend is a size 9 and she looks thinner than me. I'm a 7 as well, and well, I look far from thin.

Yes, Marilyn Monroe was chubby. This has nothing to do with me however.
I didn't say it had anything to do with you.It was just some random thought.

you could have the slimmest body but the fugliest face ever
that is beauty :rolleyes:

you could have the slimmest body but the fugliest face ever
that is beauty :rolleyes:

yeah..no kidding.

you could have the slimmest body but the fugliest face ever
that is beauty :rolleyes:
So true

Thats kinda like me.
you have a fugly face?Me too

you have a fugly face?Me too

lmao when I first read it I thought it said fullest. Then I posted what I said and then I read it again and I'm like..OH:| so I changed it lol.

I didn't say it had anything to do with you.It was just some random thought.
Like ah yeah right.

I didn't say it had anything to do with you.It was just some random thought.

Hah sorry, it's just that everytime I'm in a skinny debate, someone brings up the fact that Marilyn wasn't very thin.

Hah sorry, it's just that everytime I'm in a skinny debate, someone brings up the fact that Marilyn wasn't very thin.
I just really like her name

you could have the slimmest body but the fugliest face ever
that is beauty :rolleyes:

Call it paranoia, but are you making some sort of reference to me?

lmao when I first read it I thought it said fullest. Then I posted what I said and then I read it again and I'm like..OH:| so I changed it lol.
ohh....I still don't like my face though

Call it paranoia, but are you making some sort of reference to me?
I don't think she is your not a fugly face

ohh....I still don't like my face though

Why not? From your pics on the rating board you look really pretty.

Call it paranoia, but are you making some sort of reference to me?
no this wasnt commented at you it was a fact

From my pictures you thought I was chubby? I have no body pictures on myspace, and those are the only ones you've seen.

PS: I'm basing the size 5 thing on my older sister, but she looks chubbier because of her ginormous boobs. My friend is a size 5 and I could swear she's a 2.

I've noticed too that girls with larger boobs often look 20 lbs heavier than they would look otherwise.

Your poor sister.

Why not? From your pics on the rating board you look really pretty.
Maybe it's not fugly,I just don't like it.

She fucking loves her boobs. They make me sick though hah. I like my flat boobs and ass. :)

She fucking loves her boobs. They make me sick though hah. I like my flat boobs and ass. :)

Don't worry, your still pretty young. When I was your age I didn't have boobs, but I do now.

She fucking loves her boobs. They make me sick though hah. I like my flat boobs and ass. :)
I wish my boobs were a little bigger I'm only a size 36B:(

I wish my boobs were a little bigger I'm only a size 36B:(

I dunno, I'm also a 36B and I'm pretty happy with them. If mine grow any bigger I'd be a little scared as to what they would look like after I've had children. Talk about back problems.

I'm a 34B, and I'll be very unhappy if they get any bigger.

I dunno, I'm also a 36B and I'm pretty happy with them. If mine grow any bigger I'd be a little scared as to what they would look like after I've had children. Talk about back problems.
I just want to be a little bigger.

Forgive me if I'm wrong, but 36 B sounds like a descent size.Rather "medium" actually.

I remember when I experienced some weight gain I went up to around a 32 C, and it was ridiculously uncomfortable. I couldn't jog without wearing two sports bras because I hate the feeling of having ANTHING jiggle, and if something does jiggle guys tend to stare at it, which makes me even further more uncomfortable.

Thank god I've lost the weight with a brutal weight training routine but- I can honestly tell you a woman figure looks nicer with medium or smaller breasts for larger breasts-dubbed sexy by some- sometimes look vulgar.

Plus smaller boobs give off the appearance of a thinner, more feminine frame. But then again, girls with wider hips or larger frames (bones, etc) look nice with larger beasts.

Okay I'm done ranting.

Forgive me if I'm wrong, but 36 B sounds like a descent size.Rather "medium" actually.

I remember when I experienced some weight gain I went up to around a 32 C, and it was ridiculously uncomfortable. I couldn't jog without wearing two sports bras because I hate the feeling of having ANTHING jiggle, and if something does jiggle guys tend to stare at it, which makes me even further more uncomfortable.

Thank god I've lost the weight with a brutal weight training routine but- I can honestly tell you a woman figure looks nicer with medium or smaller breasts for larger breasts-dubbed sexy by some- sometimes look vulgar.

Plus smaller boobs give off the appearance of a thinner, more feminine frame. But then again, girls with wider hips or larger frames (bones, etc) look nice with larger beasts.

Okay I'm done ranting.
See that's thing I kinda have big hips and thighs.

Wow. I don't know if I could handle my boobs fluctuating so much in size. I'd be worried they would start to loose elasticity.

See that's thing I kinda have big hips and thighs.
Yeah Latinas are meant to have big chest, butty, and hips.

Yeah Latinas are meant to have big chest, butty, and hips.
Yeah I know....I don't know whats up with my boobs.All the other women in my family have C&D cups.They make fun of me:cry:

My mom did say they may get bigger though I hope.

Mine is a good ol 36 D, and I wouldn't have it any other way.

But if you truly think of having bigger breast, plastic surgery is an option *but your breast are average* if it doesn't grow.

But I wouldn't touch my breast even if they are small.

Mine is a good ol 36 D, and I wouldn't have it any other way.

But if you truly think of having bigger breast, plastic surgery is an option *but your breast are average* if it doesn't grow.

But I wouldn't touch my breast even if they are small.
Maybe after I'm 21 if they haven't gotten bigger by then I'll get plastic surgery.

Maybe after I'm 21 if they haven't gotten bigger by then I'll get plastic surgery.
Well yeah, but I really wouldn't do it, that's just me. But maybe I'll feel different if they were smaller.

Well yeah, but I really wouldn't do it, that's just me. But maybe I'll feel different if they were smaller.
yeah I think you would.

Wow. I don't know if I could handle my boobs fluctuating so much in size. I'd be worried they would start to loose elasticity.


I guess I have extremely stretchy skin!

I guess I have extremely stretchy skin!
Thats cool

you avatar is gross, she looks anorexic.

Don't worry, your still pretty young. When I was your age I didn't have boobs, but I do now.

Don't worry? Can you not read? I said I LIKE my flat boobs.

Whoaaa I can't believe you guys are complaining about a 36 B. I'm a 32 A. Your lucky. hahaha.

marilyn_monroe cudos too you for accepting it and liking it. NOt many people can

I'm a size 5:(

Hey wasn't Marilyn Monroe kinda chubby?

mmhmm. she was like, a size 11 or something. i think.

yeah, i dont think 5 is big... im a 0 or a double 00 and i hate it. its so hard to find clothes that fit right...

Whoaaa I can't believe you guys are complaining about a 36 B. I'm a 32 A. Your lucky. hahaha.

marilyn_monroe cudos too you for accepting it and liking it. NOt many people can
Yeah I guess we all have to learn to accept and enjoy what we have.

you avatar is gross, she looks anorexic.
maybe because she is

maybe because she is
yeah I think she is

yeahh

Ppl have stop posting about the thread question.And I completely forgot right along with them.

you can't say...it depends on a persons height and frame etc, i have seen size 00 people who don't look anorexic at all..they just have a small waist and frame...whereas some go invisible when they turn sideways

It really depends on the person's frame/body type.

I think like a size 8/9 up is kinda bigger.
I'm a 6/7 and I consider myself average, compared to the girls in my school.

i dont know my american size
but size 6/8 in england

and dont worry about boobs- if it suits your frame and build then it will be find =].
dont complain about your B either lol
silly asians only get As mostly
ah well..

I think that it all depends on your frame...but I think that anything below a 4 is too thin and anything over a size 16 is too big.....but yeah that's just me....

I think it all depends on height, bone structure, and actual body fat percentage. My sister used to be a size zero but still looked good and healthy but I have also seen girls who look desperately sick at that size. And my other sister is a size 8 currently and she is one of the skinniest people I know, and always has been. So it just depends on the person, but if I had to take a guess, what I consider a good size and whats normal for most of the people I have ever met is about a size 5 to size 11.

My jeans size is 1 Long. I just have a really small waist, I'm not like anorexic.

maybe because she is
It's a cropped photo, it's not real.

I think 8-9 and up is getting into the heavier side. I'm a 2 or 1, so eh.

My (USA sizes) size 1. I think it just depends on the persons body type & the way they are built. Oh and before you guys are like "omg a size 1! anerexic blah" , my BMI says Im average body weight. Im also short (5'1) but yeah.

I think though if you can clearly see visible fatauge on you, your either chubby or fat. Either way, chubby is a type of fat. And if you can see your ribs, you're too skinny. IMO.

I dont care about a girls size..i know beautiful girls who are 10 and up and fugly girls who are 00.

i dont know my american size
but size 6/8 in england

and dont worry about boobs- if it suits your frame and build then it will be find =].
dont complain about your B either lol
silly asians only get As mostly
ah well..
I will learn to like my B boobs;)

It really depends on the person's frame/body type.
Hmmmm.....yes that's what everybody seems to think.Thanx to everybody who posted their opinions.

Ohhh.....and I like your avatar.

I really dont understand american sizes but here in the Uk im an 8 or 10! Could someone post pictures of a celeb or something in each american size..if you know what i mean..?

I really dont understand american sizes but here in the Uk im an 8 or 10! Could someone post pictures of a celeb or something in each american size..if you know what i mean..?

I'll go look for some today;)

So it just depends on the person, but if I had to take a guess, what I consider a good size and whats normal for most of the people I have ever met is about a size 5 to size 11.

Agreed.

i think its an aesthetic thing. my best friend is a 00 but since she is so petite, she has quite a bit of.... we'll call it baby fat (because she is NOT NOT NOTTTTT fat, but is shapely....... actually, her proportions are shapelier than mine and i'm a big 4, small 6)
but, i also know girls who are a 5 and look anorexic.
i think above an 8-10, for most girls is pushing it. very tall girls or intense atheletes though need bigger sizes just because of their proportions or muscle tone, so the size thing doesn't really aply to them
personally, i'm not horrified at my size. i would prefer to be a 2, but i really don't have much fat on me and i have a good body fat % so i guess i just expect too much of myself.....
but i don't go around looking at girls and rule them out as friends for being bigger.

Like I've said before, you can't judge how big someone is by their pants size. I know a girl who has a very tiny waist but a curvy butt who is a 5. And I'm an 8 and wear a meduim shirt size and am a healthy weight. There are girls who are 8's that are chubby and girls that are 8's that are thin but just have butts or hips. It depends on the size of your butt, hips, thighs, and waist. Everything put together.

I'm 5'7 and a 9. I think the right size depends on the person's frame. I am by no means skinny, but my friends all think I'm their size and they're small. So whatever.

I'm 5'7 and a 9. I think the right size depends on the person's frame. I am by no means skinny, but my friends all think I'm their size and they're small. So whatever.

I think your a good size Not too skinny or fat.;)

I really dont understand american sizes but here in the Uk im an 8 or 10! Could someone post pictures of a celeb or something in each american size..if you know what i mean..?

Well Australia is the same as the UK. And I am pretty sure a 0 is a UK6. A 2 is a UK8. A 4 is a UK10. Etc.

You can't get 00 (UK 4's) here, well not that I know of.

One of my friends is a 6 (US 0) and she looks bigger than me. And I'm an 8-10 (2-4). So I guess it depends on each person.

Well I think I'm fat. I don't know what size I am though. I usually just buy stuff based on whether it fits or looks good. All I know is I have a pair of Size 3 shorts and they're loose on me.

But then again there's the chance that I have BDD so don't listen to me.

Well I think I'm fat. I don't know what size I am though. I usually just buy stuff based on whether it fits or looks good. All I know is I have a pair of Size 3 shorts and they're loose on me.

But then again there's the chance that I have BDD so don't listen to me.

You don't look fat in your rating threads.I love your photos.

Yeah I am not fat at all I weight 130 and it is pure muscle becasue I dance and everything and I wear a size 10-12 in pants mainly because my but is the size of china and an x small in shirts! ! So its really depends on your frame and everything it doen'st mean your fat if you wear a certain size!

The Battle Of the Aneroxics ....Aw Sexi Ur not fat Dont Worrys....

Marilyn Monroe wasn't chubby at all. She looked very healthy and had a beautiful body. I guess because of media and all, people images of fat and thin have become completely skewed, no one knows whats what anymore and its crazy. there are lots of celebrities who are obviously too thin and dont eat but they are betrayed as beautiful. Then there are also celebrities who have great healthy , more natural bodies but because of the image that media has set they are riducled and seen as 'chubby'.What media has done is very ufair and so so so many people (not ruling out myself) have become victims to the 'perfect woman' stereotype. It's ruined many lives and killed people too. but when companies send out millions of messages like you need this to be perfect, if you don't look like this you are ugly or fat, its inevitable. Businesses make money by making people feel unhappy and inadequate. anyways enough of my ranting, theres nothing i can do about it and yea its just the way things are.

Marilyn Monroe wasn't chubby at all. She looked very healthy and had a beautiful body. I guess because of media and all, people images of fat and thin have become completely skewed, no one knows whats what anymore and its crazy. there are lots of celebrities who are obviously too thin and dont eat but they are betrayed as beautiful. Then there are also celebrities who have great healthy , more natural bodies but because of the image that media has set they are riducled and seen as 'chubby'.What media has done is very ufair and so so so many people (not ruling out myself) have become victims to the 'perfect woman' stereotype. It's ruined many lives and killed people too. but when companies send out millions of messages like you need this to be perfect, if you don't look like this you are ugly or fat, its inevitable. Businesses make money by making people feel unhappy and inadequate. anyways enough of my ranting, theres nothing i can do about it and yea its just the way things are.

I agree that times have changed?

I think that Marylin had a not too skinny, not too fat body, but times have changed and people now consider size 5 chubby, which i consider a normal size.


A pic of marilyn:

Marylin pic (http://www.marilynmonroe.com/images/photos/lloyd/photo18.jpg)

I think that Marylin had a not too skinny, not too fat body, but times have changed and people now consider size 5 chubby, which i consider a normal size.




Marylin pic (http://www.marilynmonroe.com/images/photos/lloyd/photo18.jpg)

I hate that.........I'm a size 5 and I'm just fine.

It depends on your height. But definately a size 10 and up is fat to me. So just once you start hitting the double digit sizes, youre too big. But if youre short, you should really be no bigger than a size 5, maybe 7 if you dont wanna be fat. Im a size 5 but im 5'7/5'8....and I have a big butt, without it I would be like a size 3, and I consider myself to be a good normal weight.

It depends on your height. But definately a size 10 and up is fat to me. So just once you start hitting the double digit sizes, youre too big. But if youre short, you should really be no bigger than a size 5, maybe 7 if you dont wanna be fat. Im a size 5 but im 5'7/5'8....and I have a big butt, without it I would be like a size 3, and I consider myself to be a good normal weight.

Yup your a good norm weight.I'm a size 5 cause of my hips...their huge.:(

I'm a size 8 but i'm not fat. well i think i am but everyone else says its fine and whenever i get any thinner they say i look sick and anorexic. This thread is really pointless, cuz it cant be answered. It all depends on your height, muscle mass, and bone frame, everyone varies. I know people who are size 10 and they arent even pudgy.I know if i went down to a size three or something i'd be a skeleton. You can't label a certain pant size as fat, it just cant be done, well except plus sizes but thats why theyre called plus sizes.

I'm a size 8 but i'm not fat. well i think i am but everyone else says its fine and whenever i get any thinner they say i look sick and anorexic. This thread is really pointless, cuz it cant be answered. It all depends on your height, muscle mass, and bone frame, everyone varies. I know people who are size 10 and they arent even pudgy.I know if i went down to a size three or something i'd be a skeleton. You can't label a certain pant size as fat, it just cant be done, well except plus sizes but thats why theyre called plus sizes.


Yeah I don't think your fat.And we all already came to the conclusion that it depends on height and body frame and other things like that.But thanx for your input.

You don't look fat in your rating threads.I love your photos.
Aw thank you.

I don't know. I have like two sides of me, one which believes that I am not fat and another which believes I am and the fat one sort of overpowers the not fat belief.

I'm making no sense...

But basically, it depends on my mood. Yesterday afternoon I ate a craplot of food without caring because I was with people who are bigger than me. But if I'm with my best friend, who is tiny, I feel fat and don't want to eat.

I'm weird like that...

Aw thank you.

I don't know. I have like two sides of me, one which believes that I am not fat and another which believes I am and the fat one sort of overpowers the not fat belief.

I'm making no sense...

But basically, it depends on my mood. Yesterday afternoon I ate a craplot of food without caring because I was with people who are bigger than me. But if I'm with my best friend, who is tiny, I feel fat and don't want to eat.

I'm weird like that...

Hmmm......yeah sometimes I feel fat.If I'm in a good mood I feel just fine and content with my body.

I think that Marylin had a not too skinny, not too fat body, but times have changed and people now consider size 5 chubby, which i consider a normal size.


A pic of marilyn:

Marylin pic (http://www.marilynmonroe.com/images/photos/lloyd/photo18.jpg)

she is beautiful.
the media is fucked up. end of story.

Hm, in American sizes I think a 5 and up is at least chubby. Don't listen to me though, I'm used to being a 00.

That's insane. A lot of size 5 girls wear a small. Do u even know what the word chubby means? You don't have excess fat unless u are at least like a ten!

Marilyn Monroe wasn't chubby at all. She looked very healthy and had a beautiful body. I guess because of media and all, people images of fat and thin have become completely skewed, no one knows whats what anymore and its crazy. there are lots of celebrities who are obviously too thin and dont eat but they are betrayed as beautiful. Then there are also celebrities who have great healthy , more natural bodies but because of the image that media has set they are riducled and seen as 'chubby'.What media has done is very ufair and so so so many people (not ruling out myself) have become victims to the 'perfect woman' stereotype. It's ruined many lives and killed people too. but when companies send out millions of messages like you need this to be perfect, if you don't look like this you are ugly or fat, its inevitable. Businesses make money by making people feel unhappy and inadequate. anyways enough of my ranting, theres nothing i can do about it and yea its just the way things are.

This is SO TRUE! People are crazy these days.

I think heavy is a size 10 and up. I think too thin is under a szie 2 in most cases.
It depends on your build and measurments though.

That's insane. A lot of size 5 girls wear a small. Do u even know what the word chubby means? You don't have excess fat unless u are at least like a ten!

I agree with you.

jw what weight do you think someone should be if their height is 5'8-5'9 and they have an athletic build?