ok my fried always says shes fat and i tell her no shes not because most girls just say that. but she told me tha shes 150 something pounds and shes like 5" 3 or 4? is she fat?

She sounds a bit overweight but that is just what I'm hearing I have no clue becuase i don't know her bodyfat % or know what she looks like. If she is insecure about her weight tell her to start living healthier to make sure she is on track to staying fit.

not at all.

its like my sister.
she weight 148,and is 5'4

she jsut big boned.you would never be able to tell, she fits into a 2 piece wonderfully

Yes. She is fat. I'm her height so I'd know.

yep im her height and im 105 ...

noo dude, im her height and her weight, and i dont consider myself fat....ppl on this lie about their weight. alot.

Assf you didn't have to be so rude about it JERK

shes lying. shes probably obease herself.

i'm 5'4 and i weigh 98 lbs. and im not lying about my weight. anyways i do think thats fat considering that im that height so.. she should go on a diet she'd 50 lbs. overweight.

im 140 but 5'8... uhh i think she's ok like shes not fat but i mean she could loose weight if she feels uncomfortable abot herself

it depends on how much is muscle and how large her bone frame is. i way that much and i'm the same height and i think i'm fat but everybody here guesses i'm like 120 and tell me i'm not fat. and when i do tell them my real weight they say i'm not fat. i dunno. if she's like me then she's a bit of the BMI index and does and can lose weight if she wants to. it would make her average--not super thin and not super fat. kinda like how actresses use to be--where they actually had curves and REAL boobs.

monroe--prolly has a thin frame, high metabolism, and/or underweight. check BMI

i have a really accelerated metabolism and i try to take care of myself. i do not however have any sort of eating disorders, as one may think judging by my weight.

okay..since you weigh 95, and your 5'4'' and i weigh 120 and im 5'4'' your saying im over weight? your an idiot..you sound underweight marilyn_monroe.. im not saying you have an eating disorder or anything, but dont say that just because someone isnt your weight there overweight.

i'm 5'4 and i weigh 98 lbs. and im not lying about my weight. anyways i do think thats fat considering that im that height so.. she should go on a diet she'd 50 lbs. overweight.

wtf? jus cuz u weigh a certain weight n ur her size. firstly she might have musles, which weigh more then fat. n i am 5"3 n 1/4 n am 130, but i don look big, its all muscle. so jus cuz u weigh bout 50 lbs less then her doesnt mean thats the weight she should b. 4 my advice u should tell her that if she does feel that way bout herself that u 2 should start takin walks/jogs or sumthin 2gether, bcuz its easier 2 exercise with sum1 else, so u could help her fele better bout herself, while gettin the exercise u need. u kno kill 2 birds with 1 stone

i'm 5'4 and i weigh 98 lbs. and im not lying about my weight. anyways i do think thats fat considering that im that height so.. she should go on a diet she'd 50 lbs. overweight.


shut the hell up you skelton how about you think about putting on about 15 pounds.

i hate chicks that are underwigth and tell other girls there fat omg

Hmm, well, in my opinion... I wouldn't call her fat, she just might be a little chunky for her height. At 5'4, I would think that the proper weight would be around 130, but I wouldn't know.

I'm between 5'5 and 5'6, and I weigh around 150, and I consider myself fat. I have a horribly low-esteem.

Anyways, it all actually depends on their frame. For example, I don't have a small frame, but yet I don't have a large frame, I'm in between. From what I hear, girls my age should be like 120lbs, but for me, I would never be 120 and healthy at the same time. If I dropped 10lbs, I would be happy.

My point is, some one can look bigger than some one else, but that doesn't mean that they are fat. It's all in the way their body is put together. From your frame to muscle mass.

My doc says I have an athletes body. I have a lot of muscle mass, and a medium sized frame. Like I said, I'm 150, and I sometimes fluctuate to 155, but I'm perfectly healthy, but I do think I'm fat. Apparently I'm not though. Or so, that's what the doctor tells me.

shes fat. im about 5'3-5'4 also. and im chunky at 140. i used ot be 180 and i was fat. at 150 i was still chunky. i mean shes not fat fat. but shes probably chunky. but it all depends on her body type and where she holds most of her weight you know.

I wouldnt say shes fat. She probably is just big boned and has it in her genes. If shes concerned she could always try to lose some weight. But no I dont think shes sounds fat

It really depends on how big your bones are or how much muscle mass you have.

Because I am 5'4" and I weigh 150 and I am not fat (I have been working out for almost 3 months straight).

Umm...she's probably a bit chubby, but she should go to a doctor to make sure becuase she shouldn;t just start dieting and go crazy.

im 5'5 and in only 95 pounds, but i think fat is a bit of a harsh word...